Which is Best? Roth vs Traditional IRA.
The best IRA accounts are all about great investing options and low fees. Since tax season is here, now is the best time to make your IRA contributions. Luckily most of the top companies that are home to the same places where you would open up an online stock trading account. In a previous post, I ranked the best online brokers so I had a head start when it came to finding the best Roth IRA or best Traditional IRA accounts.
These IRA accounts will aim to help you save for the long term and you’ll also get a nice break on your taxes.
In 2015, one of the biggest changes to the IRA landscape is the rise of “online financial advisors (OFA), or Robo-advisors.” While the more traditional money management firms featured here still are your best bet, I included a small section on OFAs in this post, because they do warrant discussion for some people.
After looking at the IRA offerings from several firms, I recommend E*Trade as the best IRA provider for most people, based on a number of factors I’ll explain shortly.
There are three other companies still worth consideration, depending on your preferences.
A Look at the Best
Here are the 4 best IRA companies for 2015:
- TD Ameritrade
What Makes These the Best IRAs?
All of these companies offer a variety of resources beyond acting as a vehicle to establish an IRA account. Three of the four companies have office locations where you can go in and talk to a live person. TradeKing, the one that doesn’t, has cheaper fees and trading costs than the others.
Here are some more of the common features of these top companies:
- Access to a variety of investment products
- Several types of IRA accounts
- Introductory deals on rollovers or new accounts
- Access to quality support, research, and education
Since I already had a solid understanding of all the best online brokers, it was an easy transition into reviewing several of the same companies to determine the best Roth IRA and Traditional IRA accounts.
You can’t really go wrong with any of the four accounts listed below. Mostly, it’s a matter of preference because all of these accounts will be good for just about anyone.
E*Trade — Get Up to $600 for Opening a New IRA Account
E*Trade is known as one of the all-around best brokers year after year because they offer access to every investment product and resource you could possibly need. E*Trade is loaded with information on how to rollover your IRA, complete an IRA conversion, or just open a new account.
Depending on how much you deposit or transfer, you can receive up to $600 just for opening an account with E*Trade. With E*Trade, you can invest in over 8,000 mutual funds, and 1,300+ have no transaction fee. In some locations, there are E*Trade branches where you can talk to a live person, but there are only 28 locations nationwide.
5 Reasons to Open an IRA Account With E*Trade:
- Wide range of investment choices
- No account minimum
- Deposit $10k or more and trade free for 60 days
- Ranked as the #1 broker by Kiplinger’s in 2012
- Access to extensive research (Morningstar, S&P, Credit Suisse) and professional guidance
The Main Reason Not to Open an IRA Account With E*Trade:
- Trading commissions can be twice as much as some brokers
An E*Trade IRA is Best For:
- Those who want a variety of investments in their IRA
- Low-frequency traders
- Long-term mutual fund investors
TradeKing — Low Commissions and Fees
TradeKing is an online broker that only continues to improve after merging with Zecco in 2013. Both TradeKing and Zecco were ranked in my top 20 brokers, so I’m sure the combination of the two will only make things better for the new TradeKing in 2015 and beyond. TradeKing is known for providing great value, as evidenced by their low trading fee of $4.95 per stock or options trade.
If you open an IRA account with TradeKing, you’ll have access to all of their trading tools, which surpass the other best Traditional IRA and Roth IRA accounts in terms of options trading. TradeKing won’t hold your hand as much as the other full-service brokers, so their IRA account is more for self-directed investors and people looking to save money on trading costs. The savings can really add up over time even if you’re just making a few trades each year.
5 Reasons to Open an IRA Account With TradeKing:
- No account minimum
- $4.95 per trade and only $0.65 per options contract
- Ranked #1 in customer service by SmartMoney from 2010-2012
- Rated among the best options brokers by Barron’s
- Trader network allows you to see what others are doing with their money
The Main Reason to Not Open an IRA Account With TradeKing:
- Lacks the account resources of a full-service broker
A TradeKing IRA is Best For:
- Higher-frequency traders or options traders
- Self-directed investors
- Deal seekers
TD Ameritrade — Get Up to $600 for a Rollover
TD Ameritrade is ranked as one of the best online brokers for trading and even investing long term. As a client, you have access to any resource you need, from banking services to advanced trading tools and trading platforms.
If all that isn’t enough, you can receive up to $600 when you rollover your old 401k. TD Ameritrade also has Chartered Retirement Planning Counselors available to guide you step by step during your rollover so everything is covered. You’ll also have access to planning tools, like a 401k Rollover Calculator, an IRA Selection Wizard, and WealthRuler to help you plan your goals.
5 Reasons to Open an IRA Account With TD Ameritrade:
- No account minimum
- Access to 100+ no-fee ETFs
- Speak with a Chartered Retirement Planning Counselor before making any decision
- Ranked #1 by Barron’s for Long-Term Investing and Novices
- Ranked as “best broker for your IRA” in 2012 by Kiplinger’s
The Main Reason to Not Open an IRA Account With TD Ameritrade:
- Higher-than-average trading costs and fees at $9.99 per stock or options trade
A TD Ameritrade IRA is Best For:
- All levels of experience
- Those who want to rollover a 401k
- Beginners who don’t understand IRAs
- Less active investors or low-frequency traders
Scottrade — Excellent Guidance and Customer Support
Scottrade is known in this industry for their superior customer support and service. They take care of their clients, regardless of how much money you have in your account. (I personally had a great experience dealing with multiple Scottrade representatives who provided me with everything I needed to test out a Scottrade account for my review.) Scottrade also offers many of the same account features and investment products of the top full-service brokers. Their commissions are even slightly cheaper at $7 per trade.
One unique thing that helps Scottrade be home to one of the best Roth IRA and Traditional IRA accounts is their Flexible Reinvestment Program™. The program allows you to invest dividends from stocks or ETFs into other eligible stocks or ETFs without paying a commission. Basically, you collect your dividends and then put them back to work immediately, but at no cost to you. Scottrade also offers up to $1,000 cash when you open a new account (depending on how much you fund the account with).
5 Reasons to Open an IRA Account With Scottrade:
- $0 to open a retirement account
- Over 3,100 mutual funds with no transaction fee
- Over 500 branches nationwide
- Rated as highest customer satisfaction by J.D. Powers and Associates
- Decent commission prices on trades
The Main Reason to Not Open an IRA Account With Scottrade:
- Trading tools are slightly behind the curve
A Scottrade IRA is Best For:
- New investors
- People who want a full-service broker and lower commissions
Now that you have a brief idea about which IRA companies are the best, I’ll explain everything you need to know about opening an IRA account and the differences between a Roth IRA and a traditional IRA.
If you already know what you need to about Roth IRA, Traditional IRA, and other IRA accounts, I recommend skipping down to the section titled “What is an Online Financial Advisor?.”
What is an IRA?
An IRA, or Individual Retirement Account, is basically a savings account that has a lot of guidelines and restrictions. It’s the best way to invest your money to get upfront tax breaks or pay no taxes on your gains when you take your money out later in life.
While you do enjoy these tax breaks, you’ll incur a heavy tax penalty if you withdraw any funds from an IRA account before you’re 59.5 years old.
There are 11 types of IRAs, but only four are worth considering and only two will likely apply to your situation.
The 4 most common types of IRAs are:
- Traditional IRA
- Roth IRA
- SEP IRA
- SIMPLE IRA
The other popular type I didn’t include above is the Rollover IRA, which is essentially a transfer of your retirement funds from a previous job into a Roth or Traditional IRA. Rollovers are offered by all of the best IRA companies.
Two of the less commonly discussed IRAs are the SEP IRA and the SIMPLE IRA. Let me briefly tell you about those before getting to the Roth IRA and Traditional IRA, which are more popular.
SEP IRA — Also known as the Simplified Employee Pension Individual Retirement Account, this IRA allows an employer to contribute to your Traditional IRA. So instead of your employer adding money into a pension fund, it goes into your IRA as if you were investing it yourself.
SIMPLE IRA — This stands for Savings Incentive Match Plan for Employees and it’s set up very similar to a 401k plan, meaning the employer matches the contributions made by the employee.
Again, the SEP IRA and SIMPLE IRA are not overly common because the business has to set it up versus the individual who sets up a Roth IRA or Traditional IRA.
Roth vs Traditional IRA
A Roth IRA and a Traditional IRA have many of the same rules and regulations, but there are a few key differences between the two.
Traditional and Roth IRA Rules
The rules that Traditional and Roth IRAs have in common are:
- Contribution Limits
- Withdrawal Penalties
- Funding an Account
- Choosing Investments
Traditional and Roth IRA Limits
Roth IRA contribution limits and Traditional IRA contribution limits are exactly the same. In 2015, you can put in $5,500 per year if you are 49 years old or younger and $6,500 if you’re between 50 and 70.5 years old.
If you have a Roth IRA and a Traditional IRA, the maximum amount you can contribute in total is still $5,500 or $6,500, depending on your age. If you’re 40 years old, you can put $3,000 into a Roth IRA and $2,500 into a Traditional IRA. You can’t put $5,500 into both.
Regardless of which type of IRA account you choose, you’ll have to pay a 10% penalty in addition to any income tax earned on the investment if you pull your money out early.
You want to put your money into an IRA but never at the expense of having to take money out before you’re 59.5 years old. Don’t force the maximum investment amount of $5,500 each year if it stretches your finances too thin.
Funding an IRA Account
You can fund your Roth IRA or Traditional IRA cash or cash equivalents but not other assets. However, rollovers can include any asset or investment product — the IRA is not cashed out in the case of a rollover.
The best IRA accounts are limited to the investment products offered by an online brokerage. Both Traditional and Roth IRAs allow investments like stocks, bonds, mutual funds, ETFs, and more. For both Traditional and Roth, you put your money in and then allocate it to specific types of investments. The emphasis of an IRA is usually on long-term growth, so the investments should traditionally be less risky.
The Key Differences Between a Roth and Traditional IRA
- Tax Deductions
- Income Limitations
- Old-Age Restrictions
- Withdrawal Exceptions
You get tax breaks with either option, but there’s a pretty big difference in when these occur.
With a Traditional IRA, you’re allowed to deduct your yearly contribution (in most cases) off your taxable income each year. If you put in $5,500 each year into a Traditional IRA and you make $60,000 per year, you’ll only pay taxes on $54,500. (To avoid doing the calculations yourself this tax season, you can use online tax software. Check out my article on the best tax software to see the top products.)
When you withdraw your money from a Traditional IRA, it will be taxed as income, like any other investment.
A Roth IRA is not tax deductible each year so it won’t have an impact on your yearly tax return. It does hold a major tax advantage in the long run (if your account makes money). With a Roth IRA, you don’t have to pay income tax when you withdraw the money from your account at retirement.
Traditional IRAs allow anyone younger than 70.5 years old to contribute regardless of income. In order to contribute to a Roth IRA, a single filer must make less than $129,000 and married couples must make less than $191,000 combined.
You can keep your money in a Roth IRA as long as you want, but a Traditional IRA forces you to start taking distributions at age 70.5. You can’t make any contributions to a Traditional IRA after that age, but you can continue contributing to a Roth IRA as long as you’d like. Also, keep in mind that beneficiaries of Roth IRAs will not owe taxes either.
A Roth IRA also requires that you have the account open for at least five years before qualifying for a distribution. If you open an account at age 57, you’ll have to wait until you’re 62 to take the money out without penalty versus taking it out at 59.5 years old.
A Roth IRA offers a few advantages over the Traditional IRA when it comes to withdrawal flexibility. If you withdraw from your Roth IRA early, you’re only hit with a tax on the gains, not the money you put into the account.
Anything you put into a Roth IRA you can take out at anytime without being penalized. The only case where you would have to pay a penalty fee is if you withdraw from the income you’ve earned prior to being 59.5 years old.
A Traditional IRA is much different. You’ll be hit with the 10% penalty on any amount you withdraw before 59.5 years old.
Roth IRAs also add an additional layer of flexibility. First-time homebuyers are allowed to take out up to $10,000 in earnings. That money is tax-free and you will not be assessed the 10% penalty. You can take out $10,000 on a Traditional IRA as a first-time homebuyer as well without paying the 10% penalty, but you’ll have to pay taxes on the distribution.
Comparison Chart: Roth IRA vs Traditional IRA
Who’s a Roth IRA Best For?
- Younger adults without large incomes
- Those who want flexibility to take out investments
Who’s a Traditional IRA Best For?
- People who want to reduce their taxable income each year
- Adults who start an IRA account later in life
How Does a Rollover IRA Work?
A Rollover IRA is not necessarily a “type” of IRA, but more so an action. It occurs when retirement funds are transferred into a Traditional IRA or Roth IRA. Again, all of the best IRA accounts will have the capability to do a rollover. The most common rollovers are a 401k and a 403b.
You’ll want to do a Rollover IRA if you have retirement savings from your previous job and you’ve moved onto something else. If you have multiple retirement accounts, it also makes sense to consolidate your accounts in one place at some point.
You get the tax advantage of both tax-deferred and tax-free rollovers from the best IRA companies.
Avoiding a 20% Withholding Penalty on a Rollover
The top companies will also assist you with a seamless transfer from your old account to your new IRA. If the transfer is done with a check, you’ll get charged a 20% withholding penalty. Obviously, you’ll want to avoid this at all costs.
To do so, you can inform your new IRA account that you want the funds to be transferred directly from your previous account to this one. Again, all the best Roth IRA providers and the best Traditional IRA providers will assist you with this.
If you’re doing a Rollover IRA, you can choose between a Traditional or Roth IRA, but remember that all the same restrictions will apply to each IRA type.
A Deeper Understanding of IRA Accounts
The information on IRAs can go on and on. I wanted to simply give you a starting point so you have a basic understanding and you’re able to choose the best IRA account for you. If you want to dig deeper, I recommend reading Publication 950 from the IRS, which provides 111 pages worth of information on IRAs.